Can Judaism Be Saved?

Beginning to have more energy in the morning, feels good. Back to p.t. on my own. A cycle of up and down with it, wanting to return to my not long ago regular resistance and cardio. More slippery than I prefer.

Will finish Art Green’s “Can Judaism Be Saved? Its Future After Gaza” today. A short, dense, scholarly book. He’s a kabbalist, a Hasid, professor, author and Rabbi Jamie’s mentor.

Oversimplifying his closely reasoned argument. In essence: two strains of Judaism, both venerable but in direct opposition over one key aspect of the tradition–is Judaism a universal, outward focusing religion; or, are Jews the chosen people of God, set apart from other nations?

The diaspora, especially the contingent in the U.S., largely ignored this division in their desire to create a safe homeland for all Jews following the Holocaust. Universalist or believers in Jews special dispensation as God’s chosen could both agree on founding and supporting Israel as a new and young country.

Now though Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians in Gaza and on the West Bank has solidified both camps, often along generational lines with younger Jews on the universalist side and older Jews, perhaps with close family members who died in the Holocaust, on the other. Israel is their ride or die.

Art’s last chapter suggests a way forward. I’ll report back after I’ve read it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.