Category Archives: US History

Joining

Samain                                                                 Thanksgiving Moon

imagesHere’s an odd outcome of the election. I’m planning on joining Congregation Beth Evergreen. Strange, huh? Turns out you don’t have to be Jewish. Weird, to me, but true.

Why join? Well, there’s the mussar group. It’s a disciplined approach to character and spiritual development. I’ve always gravitated toward groups that encourage introspection and using that introspection to grow as a person. Mussar is intellectually satisfying, but even more emotionally so. It speaks to the everyday of lived ethics, how to be true to yourself and others. The group itself is supportive, non-judgemental, and full of bright, inquisitive folks. I’ve made the beginnings of friendships there.

jamieThen, there’s Rabbi Jamie Arnold. He’s an unusual guy: an athlete, a good musician, a composer and arranger, too, an intellectual, and an embodiment of compassion leavened with toughness. This combination of skills and character make him a compelling leader.

Kate, too, of course. She’s on her spiritual path and reveling in it. It’s a place we can both go, a place that’s more than movies or jazz or theatre, a place we can both ease our way into.

raise-your-voiceBut mostly there’s the potential for action against the impending Trump regime. Politics is not a solo sport; it requires allies. Congregation Beth Evergreen seems to have a core of folks who’ve done actual work in political situations. It clearly has a number of folks who want to do work on the Trump watch. That includes me. My politics and my spiritual journey have always been tightly wound together so working with folks at Congregation Beth Evergreen seems like a continuation.

Finally, there is, of course, Judaism. It’s so different up close. It’s long history of scholars, activists, philosophers and theologians is a rich resource as is the cultural achievement of having lasted this long as a people. I don’t feel drawn to becoming a Jew, but I can learn from the long history of Judaism, even participate in it.

And, I find I want to.

You Can Stop Waiting

Samain                                                                 Thanksgiving Moon

resistSome people say wait. Give him a chance to lead. I say, he’s had a multitude of chances already. He’s responded with mocking the disabled, promoting sexual assault, referring to immigrants as rapists and murderers, challenging a sitting Federal judge who happens to be both Latino and an American citizen. His followers chant lock her up, stop the cunt, White Power and fly the Confederate battle flag. The KKK held a celebration in honor of his election, North Carolina, and David Duke says he has ratified their beliefs.

This was all prior to the win, of course. So, would the awesome responsibility of being President of all the people change him? It did not take long to find out. Myron Ebell, appointed to head the EPA is, the NYT times writes, “…someone to follow through on his campaign vow to dismantle one of the Obama administration’s signature climate change policies, President-elect Donald J. Trump probably could not have found a better candidate for the job than Mr. Ebell.”

ammolands-america-hell-yeahThis week he appointed Mike Flynn as his National Security Adviser. Former NATO Supreme Allied Commander Admiral James Stavridis told CNBC on Friday, “I think he will play to the darker angels of this administration in terms of adopting very, very aggressive stance, very hard power, very anti-Islam,” he said in an interview with CNBC’s “Power Lunch.”

Not stopping there, he appointed former senator Jeff Sessions as attorney general. The ACLU says, “Senator Sessions once called the ACLU “un-American and communist” for “trying to force civil rights down the throats of people.””

And, of course, I’ve not mentioned either Reince Priebus or Steve Bannon. Priebus, former head of the RNC, is a party insider, a Republican’s Republican. Easy to understand this appointment.

Steve Bannon. Sigh.

do-not-be-astounded“In an interview with Mother Jones in August, Bannon acknowledged that white nationalists and anti-Semites are drawn to the so-called “alt-Right” movement.

“Look, are there some people that are white nationalists that are attracted to some of the philosophies of the alt-right? Maybe,” he said. “Are there some people that are anti-Semitic that are attracted? Maybe. Right? Maybe some people are attracted to the alt-right that are homophobes, right? But that’s just like, there are certain elements of the progressive left and the hard left that attract certain elements.” (Mother Jones, August 2016)

— In a 2011 radio interview, Bannon had a hypothesis about why progressive women vilify prominent conservative women like Michele Bachmann and Sarah Palin.

ethics“That’s why there are some unintended consequences of the women’s liberation movement,” he said, according to BuzzFeed. “That, in fact, the women that would lead this country would be pro-family, they would have husbands, they would love their children. They wouldn’t be a bunch of dykes that came from the Seven Sisters schools up in New England. That drives the left insane and that’s why they hate these women.” (Political Vindication Radio, 2011)”  Both of these quotes found here.

OK. So I waited. This all came while I was waiting. I have seen his leadership, his choices for important government positions. They are consistent with crony capitalism, crony Trumpism and the selection of mediocrities rather than the best minds possible for the jobs. Wait no more. The political apocalypse is already here.

The Fight Ahead

Samain                                                                          Thanksgiving Moon

1st-amendmentA fraught topic. It has become a canard of post-election coverage that racism and other identity based prejudices drove Trump’s outsize performance in rural America. And, there is no doubt that racism, misogyny, xenophobia, homophobia and nativism were part of Trump’s very cynical-and ultimately successful-campaign strategy.

But, nothing is monovalent. Each one of these diseases of the clash between modernism and yesterday played some role in motivating some Trump voters, maybe most of them. But, I’m not convinced they are primary, which is not the same as saying they are either insignificant or not very dangerous. They are both significant and dangerous.

97How you define is how you solve. “If I were given one hour to save the planet, I would spend 59 minutes defining the problem and one minute resolving it,” Albert Einstein said. If you have a desire to resolve the current political abyss separating the peculiar combination of the Pharaoh’s and the white working class from the rest of us, you have to decide what the problem really is.

Let’s get started on those 59 minutes. The hollowing out of the American working class has been underway since the late 1960’s. We have gradually worn away the American dream, first eliminating good paying union jobs, then creating jobs to replace them at the so-called minimum wage, all the while creating a knowledge based economy that relies on college educated workers and high technology.

540546_405303126228787_1694483271_nViolent conflict between and among members of the working class occur over the distribution of economic resources: jobs, home loans, good education, accessible and affordable health care, housing and food available at reasonable prices. This is where racism and xenophobia get reinforced as African-Americans, Latinos and recent immigrants compete with non-college educated whites for a vanishing supply of living wage jobs. There are few such jobs now available to persons with a high school education or less.

It is in the political interests of the elites, which include most if not all of you who read this blog, to keep the working classes struggling against each other. That keeps them focused on their individual circumstances and on barriers to their immediate prospects, usually seen as each other.

In this sort of analysis then a major driver for racism, misogyny, and xenophobia is economic dislocation. If this is the problem at the heart of this recent electoral tragedy, then how we get to a different electoral result relies first of all on economic policy. How can we ensure good paying jobs, decent futures for all Americans, not just those gifted by the genetic lottery with enough intelligence and cultural support to attend college? There are many answers to this question, I’ve mentioned some of them below.

bankers-or-customersIf we can become the ones who offer real solutions to this devastating economic reality, then we will gain the political support of those whose lives have been changed by them. This is not cynicism, this is politics at its highest and best purpose, resolving public problems communally.

Even if we solve these problems will the four horsemen of racism, sexism, xenophobia and nativism still exist? Yes. Of course, they will. And we must be prepared to fight them whenever and wherever they manifest.

That city on the hill Reagan kept referencing could be America, not Donald Trump’s America; but, an America rededicated to the proposition that all of us are created equal, that all of us deserve certain basics like food, housing, medical care, education, and that we as a nation are a beacon to the world, not Trump Tower.

The next four years will require our mutual dedication, time, money and influence. The clock starts today.

 

Considering Possible Next Steps

Samain                                                                             Thanksgiving Moon

We are not yet in the Trump era. Not yet. Not until January 20th. That doesn’t mean he’s not already stirring the waters. Nope. Just that he doesn’t have his hands on the levers of power right now. But, he will.

What to do? Here’s an e-mail I sent to Rabbi Jamie Arnold. I share it because I think the more we consider how to respond, the better organized we get right now, before Trump’s small hands start to twirl the nuclear codes, the better chance we stand of staving off the worst and perhaps creating space for some real advances.

Rabbi Jamie,

As I see it, they are three broad areas for action that will be necessary, not optional, over the next four years. I’m putting them in what seem like a logical order to me.

1. Climate Change   As Kevin Trenberth pointed out in his excellent presentation, we are in a critical time for climate action. There are goals we must reach as a planet by 2050 and by 2100 in order to keep the earth habitable for humans. I believe, with Thomas Berry from his fine little book, The Great Work: Our Way into the Future, that our generation’s great work is creating a sustainable presence for human beings on this planet.

2. Economic Justice I believe that the root problem exposed in this election is the hollowing out of the working class. I grew up in a small eastern Indiana town where my friend’s and classmate’s fathers worked for General Motors. Without a high school education it was possible to earn a living wage, a wage sufficient for a house, a car, advanced education for the kids, healthcare and vacations. By 1974 my vibrant home town had plywood on its main street shop windows. People closed the drapes and left town in the dead of night, unable to pay their mortgages and face their neighbors. Those good union jobs were gone. The people who held those jobs and their children voted Trump in this election.

This is a bill that is long past due. And, it affects working class people of color as well as white working class folks. These are the non-college educated folks whose lives look bleak from within their communities. Solutions to this problem are known, just not emphasized any more. They include creating affordable housing, passing substantial unemployment benefits, providing job transition education especially when whole industries collapse (think coal mining right now), making sure that health care is available to all.

This is a particularly poignant issue for those of us with a college education or beyond. We have let working class pain go untended for years while we focused on identity politics, environmental politics, immigration and LGBT rights. All of that work, successful in many cases, was important. It’s just that while we were working on those issues we let the economic future of working class families dim, then go out.

3. Defense  Another emphasis might be on rapid reaction teams that can respond to gay bashing, race baiting, rape culture and general disregard for those who are other. These teams must be ready to defend recent hard won victories like samesex marriage, the organizing of Black Lives Matter, the coalescing of women’s groups against the pussy-grabber in chief. But in my opinion this is a time for defense on these issues.

The safety-pin idea seems congruent with this action area.

I’m not imagining here what Beth Evergreen’s response to these issues could be, might be. I’m still too new to the area, two years, to have the kind of political knowledge and connections I had in Minnesota. But, I know there are local, county, state, national and international dimensions to all three of these areas. Discerning what those are and how Beth Evergreen might work on them is, to me, the next step.

Two Foci Needed Now

Samain                                                                               Thanksgiving Moon

tripleAs the sky begins to brighten over Black Mountain, this spinning Earth reminds me that after night comes the day. The gradual ratcheting down of temperature reminds me that spring follows the fallow time. The spiral nature of the days and months as they peel away from yesterday yet follow the path of the Great Wheel as they do, reminds me that mother earth preaches patience. Wait, and the season will change. Wait, and dark will become light. It is the message of the Tao. Follow the watercourse way.

It is sound counsel. No good thing lasts forever, neither does any bad thing. We could just wait and history will turn the tide against the Donald and his band of wreckers and exploders. Yet.

Turner, Bell Rock Lighthouse
Turner, Bell Rock Lighthouse

Not the way I’m made, however. As I said in an earlier post, I’m more of a take arms against a sea of troubles and by opposing end them sort of guy. It’s still early days in this sea and the waters have only begun to roil. The seas will get worse, heavier, more dangerous. It will be tempting to recruit fingers for every dike, to follow every insult with a counter move.

That would be a mistake. We have to choose which dikes must be defended. Must be. I think it’s possible to make those decisions and, if we concentrate our resources, to win some real victories. Won’t happen if we are in reactive mode all the time.

As a preliminary thought, I have two foci to recommend for our attention. This may change as circumstances arise, but right now they seem the most urgent to me.

Two articles in today’s NYT set them up.  Bernie Sanders: Where Do the Democrats Go From Here and Trump’s Climate Contrarian Myron Ebell Takes on the EPA.

These two foci have very different implications, but share a these must happen now exigency.

co2-concentration-different-scenariosFoci 1  Climate Change

This is a long term survivability issue for the human race. Unfortunately, the time frame for action to alter climate warming’s long term trajectory is now. Between 2016 and 2050 drastic reductions in carbon emissions must take place. Even more drastic ones by 2100. Without efforts more ambitious than the recent Paris Accords the human race will suffer for millennia and this planet may become too hot for us. Literally. And Trump has just appointed a climate change skeptic to head the EPA.

Foci 2 Economic Justice

This is a short term survivability issue for our nation. Democrats used to have economic justice as a key rationale for the party. Unions. Affordable Housing. Unemployment benefits. Job retraining. Financial and health resources for the elderly, the disabled and the poor. Restraints on the financial sector. Support for local economic development. Infrastructure maintenance.

6306717212_5c2a562fbe_zMore than any single cause this election laid bare the casual disregard both parties have given to these issues over the last 30 to 40 years. Clinton’s third-way moved the party farther from these bedrock issues. Obama tried, but after his first two years, the GOP became the party of obstruction, the party of no.

The narrower focus within Economic Justice must be jobs, healthcare, housing and good education for the working class. Many of the fissures in our common life root themselves in hopelessness borne of economic dislocation. Creating a solid working class for all, people of color and non-college educated whites alike, will soothe some of the most fractious.

No, I’m not saying that we ignore the very real dangers posed by racist, xenophobic, misogynistic, homophobic, cisgendered bigotry. I’m saying that there are two policy areas that rise to the top of a political program for the near term future, say through 2075.

Yes, another emphasis must be on rapid reaction teams that can respond to gay bashing, race baiting, rape culture and general disregard for those who are other. These teams must be ready to defend recent hard won victories like samesex marriage, the organizing of Black Lives Matter, the coalescing of women’s groups against the pussy-grabber in chief. But in my opinion this is a time for defense on these issues.

Again IMHO the policy focus for the next few years should be: climate change and economic justice.

Earthquake Coming

Samain                                                                             Thanksgiving Moon

sf-earthquakeDarkness has begun to settle on Shadow Mountain. Black Mountain takes out the sun at around 4 pm now and at 5 pm, the current time, evening is ready to shift over to night.

The cultural earthquakes from Tuesday’s election results have only registered as tremors so far, but the big one  is not far off. When will it come? I don’t know. I suspect after the inauguration. A police shooting here. A gay bashing there. A couple of rapes. Perhaps targeted violence against African-Americans. Maybe the National Guard sweeping aside the protesters at Standing Rock.

Those happenings will crystallize out of the solution of public anger and fear a rock hard resistance. And it will be the state against its most vulnerable citizens. Unfortunately, not a new problem. As Saul Alinsky said, the action is in the reaction. How far the call and response of bigotry will spread, how large will be the congregation that ultimately says amen is not yet known. These times are perilous, more perilous than any I have known.

When Reagan came to power, I traveled to Washington, D.C. with the Minnesota AFL-CIO. We went by bus, playing poker and drinking beer (not me, but everyone else), singing labor songs. When we got to D.C., we marched. Reagan, Reagan he’s no good, send him back to Hollywood. Reagan broke PATCO, the union of air traffic controllers and ushered in an anti-union environment that even after Bill Clinton and Barack Obama remains a national disgrace.

us-fault-lines
US Fault Lines

It was a combination of union busting, international trade deals and robots that created the rust belt and the dismal future of non-college educated folks in general and whites in particular. We have just felt the first profound shock of those choices. When people lose faith in the structures of power, they do what they can to create new ones, hopefully, they believe, better than the old one. The abandonment of the former working class by liberals and conservatives alike makes our time bereft of powerful allies for them. They’ve hoped, and voted for that hope, that somehow a billionaire who resides on the Upper East Side of New York City will do for them what others haven’t. From within their world it may have seemed like a bet worth making.

(Someone should make a map of the cultural fault lines in the U.S.)

doomsday-bunkersThis fault line within American culture has only begun to shift. It has not yet slipped, not yet allowed its full constrained force loose on our common life. Trump’s election is not that earthquake. It will follow in his wake as he takes pussy-grabbing and race-baiting to the home of the country’s first African-American president. Ironically, his predecessor.

That fault will slip. It may not come when the insults to the poor and people of color and the LGBT community mount, but it will surely come when the left behind in the white working class realize that Trump is not their friend, but an archetype of their oppressor. When that awareness dawns, head for the bunkers.

Complicit

Samain                                                             Thanksgiving Moon

Time to admit our complicity in this mess. While is there no doubt that crotch grabbing racist xenophobes have had their say, while there is no doubt that know-nothings have seized control of levers they do not understand, while there is no doubt that license has just been given to violent police actions and violent action against whoever is the other, we cannot turn aside from our implication in this disaster.

We? Yes, you, the college educated. Yes, you, the climate change activist. Yes, you, the LGBT champion. Yes, you, the Black Lives Matter protesters. And, yes, even you, the brave folks of Standing Rock.

What? We have allowed identity based politics and the politics of climate change to blind us to the real, often more urgent demands of economic justice. It’s irony so thick it would require an obsidian blade to cut. Oddly enough what we just experienced was class warfare waged from within the very camp of those who have made such a struggle necessary. That is, the party of capitalism, of big business, of Citizen’s United nominated a man for president who claimed the mantle of working class champion. And, due to their own flaws and fears, working class non-college educated white folks followed him.

Trump reminds me of the pied-piper, offering a fun-filled, immigrant-bashing, race-baiting, pussy-grabbing jaunt out of town to a good place, a place with green grass and blue skies, a place filled with winning and winning and lots of guns. Only there is no such place. It’s really more of the same distractions the 1% have used for years, the American political equivalent of 77 virgins. Hear, strap on this Trump pin and help him blow up America. What’s that? A job? Oh, sure. Look, over here! Someone coming to take your guns and the job you might have had if we hadn’t just moved our company overseas.

How are we complicit? First, they came for the unions. And we did nothing. Then, they came for good-paying working class jobs. And we did nothing. Next, they let an antiquated educational system churn out high-school diplomas so worthless they were of no use in hunting for and finding work. And we did nothing. When the banks came for their homes, we stood by and did nothing. When the floods and the hurricanes and the droughts and the wildfires created disproportionate damage to working class folks, we stood by and did nothing. Even the one place where we did do something, Obamacare, it was so flawed that it may well collapse.

We have, as a culture, and as an educated and moneyed elite, ignored fundamental political matters. Each family needs a way to provide for itself, to have a home, food, a decent education, health care. When these key components of life are made difficult or impossible to obtain, a political price will eventually be paid. That note just came due.

Economic justice, an egalitarian distribution of the fruits of our common life, is central to a just and fair politics. It cuts across race, gender, sexual preference, ethnic origin. By allowing the perversions of capitalism to gut whole demographics, we, the moneyed and educated elite, have let our own comfort trump effective policy for the working class.

The good news here is that the way out of this political swamp, Drain the Trumpian Swamp!, is known. All it requires is political will. We need solid unemployment benefits, training in crafts and skills, support for retraining as soon as jobs are lost (see coal mining, for example), real healthcare access, support for unions, affordable housing and higher taxes on the 1% to fund all this. This is the program that can unite people of color with working class whites.

Let’s get to work.

Hate Dominated by Fear

Samain                                                                      Thanksgiving Moon

johann-wilhelm-cordes-the-wild-hunt-1856-57
johann-wilhelm-cordes-the-wild-hunt-1856-57

We have experienced something dark, disturbing and powerful, an election in which the id drove our common choice. Kate said, “Hate has won.” Yes. But not only hate. Fear. And, even worse, hate dominated by fear.

The most prescient article I read, and I read hundreds, cautioned American liberals and leftists not to take the polls too seriously. I tried to find the article, but couldn’t. It was written by a Brit, an opponent of the Brexit decision and a man who awoke to a decision by his countryfolk that defied polls and pundits. He reminded us of the European turn toward nativism, French, Austrian and German movements in particular. And, he said, it could easily happen in the U.S. It has.

american-dream-post-war-abundance-swscan00536-copyAs I wrote earlier, I’m not a man given to despair and I don’t feel it this morning, this terrible wakin’ up mornin’ when the American dream has ghosts and rapists and Confederate flag waving, gun toting white men ranging uninhibited in it. This election is, I believe, a result of that dream dissipating like puffy cumulus clouds pounded by hurricane force winds. A dream denied, hopes crushed. What happens to the heart when the future dims?

Of course, you can ask any woman, any African-American or Latino, any member of the LGBT community. Ask any of the native Americans on the ground in North Dakota today. Ask any group that has existed on the fringe of the American experiment. They know what happens to the heart when the future dims.

Today that same disillusion among white working class men and women has pounded on the door of our destiny. Yes, the irony is thick, but the political dilemma of persons shunted to the side of history contains the seeds of revolution.

In part I do not despair because I have read history. The United States is not the first great power to be brought low by economic dislocation of a former privileged class. Paul Kennedy’s, The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers, proposed a mechanism for great power collapse. Military overreach strains domestic budgets and can create misallocation of economic resources. The resulting economic woes, Kennedy suggested, create the conditions for dissent at home, dissent that can wreck political unity.

union-foreverIt remains to be seen whether the toxic stew cooked up by the Donald’s political base will poison our common life and prove fatal to this long experiment in democracy. I doubt that it will. I believe we are, still, stronger than the darker angels of our nature.

Lincoln, that stalwart of the old GOP, said it best:

“We are not enemies, but friends. We must not be enemies. Though passion may have strained, it must not break our bonds of affection. The mystic chords of memory will swell when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature.”

 

It’s Trump or It’s the End of America. Not.

Samain                                                                   Thanksgiving Moon

conservativeWell. The countdown clock is at 0 days and 18 hours as I write this. No more nattering, punditing, analyzing, fearing or hoping. Now it’s time for the votes. For the breathless ring of “We’re calling this state for…” An article posted on Real Clear Politics has it exactly right: “Half of America is about to get gut punched.” If you want to see how the stakes look from the red side, read this short screed from Nevada: It’s Trump or It’s the End of America.

No, it’s not. Even Trump gets elected it’s not the end of America. But. No matter the victor the anguish driving guys who wear the inflammatory t-shirts at Trump rallies will not disappear. One of those t-shirts I saw read:  Rope. Tree. Journalist. Some Assembly Required. This is a level of uncivil discourse I would expect at a KKK rally. Oh, wait.

warrenRead a short line somewhere that said re-examination precedes renewal. My hope is that this election is a re-examination of the American political contract, of what it means to be a nation. I’m far away from my anarchist days when I wished for the Balkanization of the states, the U.S. divided into regional countries. We need each other, red and blue, white and black, brown and yellow. We need each other because ours is a country built on an idea, not a people. We become a people only when that idea ties us together.

That idea, flawed as its execution has often been, is that all peoples can come here and become part of us, can become equal to us, can become the future of our country. That all those people must consent to be governed. That that governance should and can be realized through open and free elections.

Foreigners come here not out of a love for America, but for a love of the cradle-to-grave welfare state that America has become. Eighty percent of them (or higher) will vote Democrat forever more to keep the welfare checks coming. That’s Hillary’s plan.” It’s Trump or it’s the end of America  This quote is a direct denial of the central idea behind our experiment. That this nativist idea or something similar seems to be driving the political push for Trump actually reveals the opposite of Mr. Root’s claim.

10382621_10152590956549090_5111343193235725029_nLove of America comes from all of us boat people, all those whose ancestors sailed here from Europe, even those brought here against their will, all those who walked across the border in search of a better life, all those who flew here from parts of the world in crisis or in economic disarray. That’s all of us with one notable exception: the native americans.

And look at the news as this election day looms ahead. It’s native americans who stand in defense of water and against another pipeline carrying the drug to which we are well and truly addicted: oil. In other words even the peoples who have suffered the most as this country grew use its political system, its history of protest and the power of individuals when collected together. This is the America I love. The one we need to protect with our votes and our continued alertness over the next four years.